If St. James Plantation has fewer than 200 buildable lots left, why did its single-family homes sell for less in the 12 months ending October 1, 2026 than in the 12 months before? The headline medians on the portals don't answer that question. Comparing the two years of closed sales does. St. James has become a resale market, and resale markets follow different rules than markets that builders control.
If you are deciding between St. James and the other gated golf communities along the Brunswick County coast, this changes how you shop. Buyers here are no longer waiting for lots or competing over them. They are choosing among existing homes that sellers have to price against one another.
Two Years of Single-Family Sales, Side by Side
Brunswick County Association of Realtors FlexMLS data, pulled October 8, 2026, compares closed single-family sales in St. James over two 12-month periods. The comparison covers detached homes only. Condos, townhomes and vacant homesites are not included.
| St. James single-family closings | Sept. 30, 2024 to Oct. 1, 2025 | Sept. 30, 2025 to Oct. 1, 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Homes sold | 151 | 212 |
| Average sale price | $876,496 | $826,373 |
| Average price per heated sq. ft. | $293.74 | $277.87 |
| Average days on market | About 70 | About 93 |
These are averages, not medians, and a few large sales can move an average. Home size held steady, though. In both periods the average home sold had about 2,930 heated square feet. A smaller mix of homes did not cause the 5.7% drop in average price over the latest 12 months. Price per square foot fell from $293.74 to $277.87 over the same window. Comparable houses brought less money, and they sat on the market about three weeks longer on average.
Sales volume moved the other way. Sixty-one more single-family homes closed in the latest 12 months than in the year before, an increase of more than 40%. Demand is still there. What changed is how many homes are for sale and how each one is priced.
The Builders Have Mostly Finished
The Town of St. James's Comprehensive Plan VII tracks the decline. The Town approved 273 permits for new residential construction in 2021 and 41 in 2025. The plan expects "little change" for residents over the next several years, because the scarcity of buildable lots limits new construction.
Scarce land usually pushes prices up. In St. James, scarcity applies to lots. It does not apply to houses. A buyer who wants a 3,000-square-foot home near a fairway can choose among several existing homes listed by owners. That buyer does not need to win a homesite and then wait on a builder. When more owners list in the same year, buyers can compare one home with the next, and the average price per square foot reflects that comparison.
The new construction that remains is small and specific. The Town's October 2026 newsletter counted eight new-construction permits in September, among them the first four-unit townhouse building at Founders, part of the Founders Row townhome collection inside the Plantation. The Town plan also identifies a cottage project between Club Villas and Members Club Drive. One in-town parcel between the main gate and Middleton Boulevard was once planned for 263 homes. It has been revised to all-commercial use, with a proposed fifth gate connecting Oceanic Drive to NC 211. That change removes housing that might otherwise have competed with resales.
What a Resale Market Means for an Offer
In a builder-led market, the price is set on a sales sheet and the buyer chooses upgrades. In a resale market, every house carries its own record: when the kitchen was last updated, how the floor plan has aged, whether the lot faces a pond, a fairway or the woods. Golf-course views, pond views, location, condition, floor plans and updates all move value in St. James. When two homes of similar size list near each other, the differences between them show up in price per square foot.
In practice, this past year rewarded buyers who compared homes before writing an offer. Ninety-three days is the average. Homes that sold in the first week and homes that sat for six months both feed into that number. Once a St. James listing has passed the three-month mark, it has been on the market longer than the typical sale. You can bring comparable sales into that conversation. A buyer who wants a specific location, such as a marina-area street or a particular course, still faces a small set of homes. In that case it matters more to know which neighbors sold recently, and for how much, than to know the average.
For a seller, the same math runs in reverse. A home listed at last year's price per square foot is competing against neighbors who have already adjusted. We cover how that early pricing decision plays out in our guide to the most common mistakes when pricing your home for sale. The same pattern showed up across the river in our look at Leland's spring sales, where more closings came with longer waits.
The county as a whole moved differently. The Brunswick County Association of Realtors reported 579 sales countywide in September 2026, with a median sale price of $385,000, up 2.7% from September 2025. Those are countywide medians across all price points, so they don't compare directly with St. James averages. They do show that the easing in St. James reflects how its own inventory has matured. It is not a countywide slump.
The Next Large Supply Sits Across NC 211
The next big wave of housing in the Town of St. James will sit outside the Plantation gates. St. James North is a development of roughly 140 acres across NC 211 from the Plantation, surrounding the Town Hall and Event Center complex. The Town Council voted on the project in April 2026, and the homes planned there will sit within town limits but outside the original St. James Plantation. The applicants are Harbor Development Corporation, D.R. Development Corporation and Canal Associates, LLC.
The scale is large compared with what remains inside the gates. According to the Town's staff memo on the request, the developers propose up to 1,902 single-family, townhouse and multifamily homes in all. A separate Town financial analysis uses 1,250 units as its working estimate. The plan proposes a grocery store, other retail, dining and offices, and the Town expects the grocery store to be the first building.
The timing is years away. The concept plan's phasing estimate has commercial construction beginning around 2026 and running to 2030 or 2032. It has multifamily construction starting around 2027. In its August 2026 zoning report, Town staff were waiting on a revised site plan for the St. James North shopping center and planned to ask the developer for an updated infrastructure timeline. For a buyer this winter, St. James North will mean a closer grocery store before it means new housing that competes with Plantation resales.
The Road and the Water Lines
Two infrastructure projects will shape daily life for anyone who moves in over the next year. At an August 20, 2026 work session, NCDOT reported that the NC 211 widening was 72% complete. Substantially all roadway work is expected by July 2027, and the full project is scheduled to finish in January 2028. Girder installation for the Midway Road bridge is targeted for around December 1, with a nighttime traffic detour during that work. NCDOT has said it will give at least two weeks' notice before delayed storm drain work at the St. James main entrance begins.
The joint Town and Brunswick County water pressure project is about $6 million, with $1.9 million of the Town's American Rescue Plan funds. It is designed to raise water pressure across the system and bring about 900 homes above 40 psi. The new pressure zone along NC 211 and NC 906 was expected to be finished in early October. A final phase will improve pressure on the west side of town, including the Woodlands. If you are comparing homes on the west side of town, ask the seller about water pressure at that address.
Questions Buyers Ask About St. James Right Now
Are condos and townhomes following the same trend? The sales comparison above covers detached single-family homes only. Condos, townhomes and lots trade in much smaller numbers and need their own comparable sales. For a condo search, use recent condo closings, not the single-family averages.
Is building a custom home still an option? Yes, but with fewer than 200 buildable vacant lots left in the Plantation and 41 new-construction permits issued in 2025, the choice of sites is narrow. Most buyers will be choosing among existing homes.
If you own in St. James and want to know where your home falls against the 212 single-family sales from the last 12 months, The Chris Luther Real Estate Team will price it against the comparable homes nearby, not the county headline. Request Your Free Coastal Home Valuation or browse our St. James neighborhood guide.